Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese for Two Without Bacon

This stovetop mac and cheese makes two main servings with mashed butternut squash in the sauce. A little butter and flour help the milk coat the macaroni, and cheddar goes in after the pan comes off the heat. There is no bacon to fry and no second bake to dry out the pasta.

The starting quantity is 4 ounces of dry elbow macaroni and 1 cup of peeled squash cubes. Serve it as dinner for two or divide it into four smaller side portions. The stated yield is two main servings. Preparation and cooking times are estimates, with the pasta and squash cooking partly at the same time.

Recipe development note: This formulation has not been kitchen-tested. Times and yields are estimates; follow the texture, doneness and product checks.

Squash, macaroni and a small cheese sauce

Cut the peeled squash into small, similar pieces. Large cubes take longer to soften and are harder to mash smoothly. Buy a prepared squash portion if you prefer, but check its size and trim any tough peel before cooking.

Grate the cheddar before starting the sauce so it is ready to melt. The listed cup measure is approximate; the 85 g weight is the more consistent guide. A sharp cheddar gives more noticeable cheese flavor alongside the sweetness of the squash.

Reserve the pasta water before draining, then keep it in a separate cup. You may not need the full amount. Add it by the tablespoon at the end rather than pouring it into the measured milk at the beginning. The flour belongs in the butter mixture, where it can cook before liquid is added.

The four-stage stovetop method

Step 1: Cook the squash and macaroni

Put the squash in a small saucepan, cover with water and bring to a simmer. Cook for about 10–12 minutes, until a fork passes easily through the cubes. Meanwhile, cook the macaroni in a second pan according to its package directions. Reserve 1/4 cup pasta water before draining the pasta. Drain the squash thoroughly.

Step 2: Mash the squash and start the sauce

Mash the soft squash with a fork or potato masher until there are no firm pieces; a little texture is expected with a fork. Melt the butter in the empty pasta pan over medium-low heat. Stir in the flour and cook for about one minute, stirring so it does not darken or stick.

Step 3: Add milk, squash and cheddar

Gradually whisk the milk into the butter and flour. Stir over gentle heat for about 2–3 minutes until lightly thickened. Stir in the mashed squash, garlic powder, salt and pepper and heat through. Remove the pan from the heat, then stir in the cheddar in small handfuls until melted. Avoid boiling the cheese sauce.

Step 4: Fold in the pasta and adjust

Fold the drained macaroni into the sauce. If it is too thick to coat the pasta easily, stir in reserved pasta water one tablespoon at a time. Let the pasta stand briefly in the warm sauce, then divide between two bowls and serve. If it needs more heat, warm it gently while stirring rather than bringing it to a hard boil.

Keeping the sauce smooth and spoonable

A sauce can turn grainy if cheese is added to a very hot or boiling mixture. Take the pan off the heat first and add small amounts of grated cheese. This gives each handful time to melt without prolonged high heat.

Squash moisture and pasta shapes vary. Start with the measured milk and drained squash, then use the held pasta water to loosen the finished sauce. For a smoother squash texture, mash thoroughly before mixing; do not expect a fork-mashed sauce to match a fully blended purée.

Portion changes and ingredient choices

Use another small pasta shape with a similar package cooking time, keeping the dry weight at 4 ounces. This is a milk-and-cheddar formulation containing wheat and dairy. A dairy-free or gluten-free version needs separate texture checks. Omit the garlic powder if you prefer a simpler flavor. The guide is written for the stovetop, so adding an oven bake would change the moisture balance.

Cooling and reheating extra pasta

Refrigerate leftovers in a shallow covered container within two hours, or one hour if the room is above 90°F (32°C). Keep at 40°F (4°C) or below and use within three to four days. Reheat until the center reaches 165°F (74°C), stirring so the middle heats evenly. A small splash of milk or water can loosen the sauce. Reheated pasta will be softer than the fresh batch.

Questions about this recipe

Can I use frozen squash cubes?

Cook them according to the package guidance until completely tender, then drain well and mash. Frozen cubes can release more water, so be cautious with the optional pasta water.

Does this need cream or bacon?

Neither is included. Milk, butter, cheddar and cooked squash form the sauce. The flavor will differ from a bacon-based roasted version.

Can I double the quantities?

Use larger pans with enough space to stir the sauce and pasta. Keep the same texture checks and add the reserved water gradually; doubling does not mean twice as much adjustment water will be needed.

Printable recipe card

Serve with air fryer Brussels sprouts for two · Browse all recipes